The Gun Control Debate is at a Stalemate. Can Smarter Weapons Help to Solve it?

Aug 20, 2019

2 min

Selmer Bringsjord

The gun control debate is at a stalemateAmerica seems incapable of finding common ground on background checks, waiting periods, weapons registries and restrictions or bans on select weapons. Shooting after shooting has resulted in decades of debate but little substantive change.


But Professor Selmer Bringsjord from Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, who recently weighed in on the issue, presented a concept that could turn the entire topic on its head by using artificial intelligence.


Bringsjord accepts that America won’t get rid of its guns – so why not just make our guns smarter?  Ethically AI-enabled weapons can put American politicians back to work by shifting the debate from the weapons we should ban, to the targets we will accept. Do we allow guns to kill school children, shoppers, concert-goers? The technology of ethical AI changes the conversation.  


His idea was just recently published in the Times Union:


“Yet there is a solution, a technological alternative to the fruitless shouting match between politicians: namely, AI — of an ethical sort. Guns that are at once intelligent and ethically correct can put an end to the mass-shooting carnage.


Consider the rifle apparently used by the human killer in the El Paso Walmart shooting. But now suppose that time is turned back to before his shots were fired on Aug. 3, and that his rifle, radically unlike the stupid one that killed, is both intelligent and ethical. This alternate-future rifle would know that it's approaching the Walmart by car and would accordingly know that it has no business being used anytime soon. Move forward in time a bit; the rifle is now in the hands of the aspiring, ear-muffed killer outside his car; but his weapon has fully disengaged itself and is locked into a mode of utter uselessness with the finality of a sealed bank vault. On the other hand, the guns in the hands of law enforcement officers who have dashed on scene know in whose hands they rest, and accordingly know that if they are trained on the would-be killer, they have every right to work well, if this criminal reveals some new threat.


Notice: If people who don't actually pose a threat sufficient to warrant being shot by police can't be shot by smart, ethical guns, a fact that could lead to the welcome evaporation of a different but also vitriolic political shouting match.” -Times Union, August 16, 2019


Could AI be the answer to America’s gun problem? It’s truly a new perspective on an old issue. If you are a reporter covering this topic, let our experts help with your story.


Dr. Selmer Bringsjord is the Chair of the Department of Cognitive Science expert in logic and philosophy, specializing in AI and reasoning. Dr. Bringsjord regularly speaks with media about AI and is available to speak about the concept of intelligent, ethical guns. Simply click on his icon to arrange an interview.



Connect with:
Selmer Bringsjord

Selmer Bringsjord

Director, Rensselaer AI & Reasoning Lab; Professor, Cognitive Science and Computer Science

Expert in logic and philosophy, specializing in AI and reasoning

Artifical IntelligencePhilosophical Foundations of AIComputational EconomicsAI SystemsFormal Logic

You might also like...

Check out some other posts from Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute

2 min

Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute Launches New Quantum Computing Minor to Prepare Next Generation of Quantum Professionals

The School of Science at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (RPI) has launched a new minor in quantum computing, positioning students at the forefront of one of the most rapidly developing fields in technology. The minor leverages RPI's unique status as the first university in the world to house an IBM Quantum System One on campus, providing students with unprecedented access to utility-scale quantum computing technology. The minor, which is now available to all currently enrolled students, requires four courses drawn from physics, computer science, mathematics, and engineering. The curriculum provides both theoretical foundations and practical exposure to quantum hardware and software, and gives students a leg up in a field rapidly approaching quantum advantage — the point at which quantum systems outperform classical computing approaches on meaningful tasks. "The quantum computing minor will augment the training of RPI students with insight into an emerging technology that will reshape industries from pharmaceuticals to artificial intelligence," said Steven Tait, Ph.D., Dean of the School of Science. "With direct access to the IBM Quantum System One, our students will gain hands-on experience with cutting-edge tools that are not yet widely available. This minor equips them with the interdisciplinary foundation needed to understand and contribute to quantum-enabled innovation." The minor arrives at a pivotal moment in quantum computing's evolution. IBM's demonstration of quantum utility in 2023 marked the beginning of an era in which quantum systems serve as scientific tools to explore complex problems in chemistry, physics, and materials science — areas where quantum advantage offers transformative potential. Hannah Xiuying Fried, graduating this December, is one of the first students to declare the minor. “I'm not a physics or computer science major, so it allows me an accredited way to prove a relevant background to future employers,” she said. “It prepares me for graduate school where I plan to continue pursuing quantum hardware research.” Currently enrolled students may declare the minor now and pursue it alongside their established degree programs. Interested students should contact Chad Christensen at sciencehub@rpi.edu.

2 min

RPI to Host Holiday Concert and Troy Victorian Stroll Kickoff December 6

RPI President Martin A. Schmidt ’81, and his wife, Lyn, invite the Capital Region to join them for the RPI Holiday Concert and Troy Victorian Stroll Kickoff, which will take place on Saturday, December 6, at 7 p.m. in the Concert Hall of the Curtis R. Priem Experimental Media and Performing Arts Center (EMPAC) on RPI’s campus. This event is free and open to the public, and a reception with refreshments will follow. The concert, titled “Light in Winter,” will include performances from the RPI Wind Symphony, Concert Choir, and Orchestra, all under the direction of Robert Whalen, RPI lecturer in music and conducting. For the second year in a row, the concert will also serve as the kickoff for the 43rd annual Troy Victorian Stroll, made possible through RPI’s partnership with the Rensselaer County Regional Chamber of Commerce. “This concert is a wonderful opportunity for our students, who work so hard all year, to share their passion for music and create something meaningful for the entire community,” said Whalen. The program, following a “Light in Winter” theme, celebrates the various ways we bring light and joy to the darker winter season. “There is a common connection across cultures of lighting up the darkness in the late fall and winter, said Whalen. “Consider Diwali, Hannukah, Christmas, Alban Arthan, and others. Music and the arts, as well as education, each represent a way of sharing our inner creative light to illuminate the darkness.” During the concert, students will perform music by Smetana, Tchaikovsky, Gershwin, Lauridsen, and Saint-Saens, all following the “Light in Winter” theme. The program will feature two winners of the 2025 RPI Concerto Competition, Reese Bush '27 in Saint-Saens' "Introduction and Rondo capriccioso" for Violin and Orchestra, and Avery Roach '25 singing Gershwin's gorgeous and evocative "Summertime". Performers across the three groups represent 160 students from 34 different majors and all 5 schools, a reminder of just how curious and well-rounded RPI students are, and that art and science don’t just coexist, they actually enhance each other. The opportunity to continue growing as a musician while pursuing an engineering degree is something that connects many of us and inspires the music we create,” said Bush. “We’re excited to share our hard work and passion with the community.” The Holiday Concert is an annual tradition that celebrates peace and unity, the creativity and hard work of RPI students, and the confluence of science, engineering, and art. Combining the concert with the Troy Victorian Stroll has been a great opportunity for RPI to partner with its home city and further engage with the community. RSVP here: Media are welcome to attend.

2 min

“Lake Health Under the Microscope: RPI Researcher Offers First Real-World Look at Herbicide Impact”

In a recent Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute news release “RPI Collaborates on First-of-its-Kind Research Study to Keep New York Lakes Healthy,” Dr. Kevin Rose is featured as the essential expert behind an unprecedented field study of the aquatic herbicide florpyrauxifen-benzyl (FPB / ProcellaCOR) in New York lakes. As Director of the Darrin Fresh Water Institute (DFWI) at RPI, Rose helped lead the research team that examined long-term, real-world behaviour of the herbicide—discovering that while it disappears rapidly from open water, it lingers in lake-bed sediments for over a year and even spreads beyond original treatment zones. Rose’s involvement highlights his role in translating cutting-edge freshwater science into actionable insights for lake managers, regulators and communities. “New products are occasionally introduced into ecosystems as we work to prevent harm from threats like invasive species,” says Rose. “Many of these tools can bring tangible benefits, but it’s essential to understand their long-term impacts and potential unintended consequences.” Dr. Rose’s leadership brings clarity to an issue that can easily be oversimplified in public debate. By grounding the study in real-world field data rather than controlled laboratory assumptions, he provides a more accurate picture of how aquatic herbicides travel, transform, and linger in lake systems. His work highlights why science-based lake management — informed by long-term monitoring — is critical for maintaining the health, resilience and recreational value of New York’s freshwater ecosystems. For journalists covering invasive species, lake health, climate resilience, herbicide use or the future of freshwater ecosystems, Dr. Kevin Rose is an essential source. He brings both scientific authority and real-world relevance to a topic that affects communities, policy decisions and environmental outcomes across the state.  Click on his icon now to arrange an interview today.

View all posts