The Great Recession: The downturn that wouldn’t end

Nov 8, 2019

3 min

Narayana KocherlakotaLisa KahnDavid Primo

The Great Recession ended 10 years ago, but University of Rochester economist Narayana Kocherlakota says it is still very much with us.


David Primo, associate professor of political science and business administration, agrees that the country continues to feel the effects of the recession, though his take differs from Kocherlakota’s.


And Lisa Kahn, a professor of economics at the University of Rochester, sees another lasting effect from the Great Recession.


“Unemployment is very low right now, leading people to think that we’ve recovered,” says Kocherlakota. “Income levels, however, are now as much as 15 percent below where they might have been, if not for the recession.”


Many economists blame the income slowdown on a natural decrease in the rate at which new ideas are discovered. But Kocherlakota, former president of the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, attributes it to something else. “Businesses don’t want to lock up money in physical investments because they’re nervous about another Great Recession,” he says. “That’s why there’s less innovation, and that’s why we have an income slowdown.”


The Great Recession began in December 2007 after the bottom fell out of the US housing market. That was followed by a shortage of assets in the financial markets and the collapse of the financial sector, including banks, credit card companies, and insurance companies. The recession, the worst in the US since the Great Depression of the 1930s, officially lasted through June 2009, though unemployment levels didn’t peak until October of that year.


According to Primo, the losers were homeowners, among others. The banks, which many observers say bear some responsibility for the recession, were bailed out by the government, while homeowners were not. That perceived double standard has led to the Occupy Movement, support for Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders, and the election of Donald Trump, according to Primo.


“Economists may be 100 percent correct in saying it was necessary to bail out the banks,” says Primo. “But that’s a difficult political argument to hear if you lost your house, while banks were bailed out.”



Says Kahn: “Many firms take the opportunity provided by a recession to introduce technologies that reduce their reliance on workers. In the old days, we had bank tellers giving out money; now machines can do that,” she says. “In manufacturing, we’re shifting more and more to machines instead of workers. And a lot of that shift takes place during recessions.”


Kahn points out that wages and employment have been falling for the last 30 years in exactly the types of jobs that are increasingly performed by machines.


Kahn identifies an additional recession-related phenomenon, one that specifically targets college graduates. “It has always been bad to graduate during a recession,” says Kahn. “But the lost earnings from the Great Recession are much larger than they were in previous downturns, and it’s something that will stay with them long term.”


Not only are fewer jobs available, the graduates find themselves competing against experienced workers who had recently been laid off. The net result is persistently lower wages.

Connect with:
Narayana Kocherlakota

Narayana Kocherlakota

Louis and Henry Epstein Professor of Business Administration at the Simon School of Business

Kocherlakota's economics expertise includes the Federal Reserve Bank and monetary policy

Federal Reserve BankFederal Reserve Monetary PoliciesThe FedCentral BanksU.S. Federal Reserve
Lisa Kahn

Lisa Kahn

Helen F. and Fred H. Gowen Professor in the Social Sciences

Kahn's research focuses on labor economics with interests in organizations and education

Job MarketLabor EconomicsJob Market for GraduatesEconomic DownturnsContract Theory
David Primo

David Primo

Ani and Mark Gabrellian Professor, Professor of Political Science and Business Administration, Department Chair

An expert in American politics; campaign finance; corporate political strategy, social responsibility & fiscal policy; & airline industry.

US National DebtCorporate PoliticsCorporate & Business StrategyCorporate ValuesCorporate Boycotts
Powered by

You might also like...

Check out some other posts from University of Rochester

Who Will Lead the U.S. Senate? Gerald Gamm Can Explain the Stakes. featured image

2 min

Who Will Lead the U.S. Senate? Gerald Gamm Can Explain the Stakes.

Sen. Chuck Schumer of New York is facing a challenge from Sen. Chris Van Hollen of Maryland for the position of Senate majority leader, setting up an unusual contest over who will lead Democrats as they prepare to take control of the chamber. University of Rochester political scientist and historian Gerald Gamm is uniquely positioned to lend insight on the negotiations, the gamesmanship, and what the outcome could mean for the Senate and the Democratic Party. Gamm is co-author of Steering the Senate (Cambridge University Press, 2025), a study of the history, evolution, and institutional power of Senate leadership. The book has been called “essential reading for all who care — or worry — about the past and future of institutional leadership and capacity on Capitol Hill” “the best book we have about the organizational development of the Senate,” and “a masterpiece . . . that unearths new information on the emergence of leadership institutions and the role of parties and showing their relevance for the Senate of today.” He can discuss: • What makes this leadership challenge historically unusual and what it reveals about the Democratic caucus. • The power and influence wielded by the Senate majority leader and how that power is exercised. • The competing political and ideological interests shaping the contest. • What the fight reveals about the Democratic Party’s priorities and its approach to governing. • How the outcome could affect the Senate’s legislative agenda and its relationship with the White House. Gamm’s research focuses on American politics, political parties, and institutional developments and historical change, legislatures, and political parties. Connect with him by clicking on his profile.

Do School Cellphone Bans Improve Learning? featured image

2 min

Do School Cellphone Bans Improve Learning?

Do school cellphone bans improve student learning? New research is adding evidence to a debate playing out in school districts across the country. A national study by researchers at Harvard University and Dartmouth College who analyzed data from 3.3 million students in 4,600 schools found that strict cellphone bans requiring students to lock their phones in pouches during the school day were associated with modest improvements in reading and math scores. They figured the rise was equivalent to one to two additional weeks of learning per year. University of Rochester economist David Figlio, whose research examines the effects of cellphone restrictions on student outcomes, can help put the findings in context. A study of Florida schools that Figlio co-authored with Umut Özek of the RAND Corporation, found that cellphone bans were associated with improved test scores in the second year of implementation, as well as reductions in unexcused student absences. Figlio offered his insights on the latest national research to reporters at The New York Times and Chalkbeat. He described the analysis of phone-pouch policies as persuasive while raising questions about the study’s findings on statewide restrictions. At the same time, he praised the study for being transparent about the challenges of analyzing differences between states. For journalists covering the issue, Figlio can discuss: • What research reveals about the relationship between cellphone restrictions and student achievement. • Whether school cellphone bans are likely to produce lasting improvements in learning. • The effects of cellphone restrictions on student attendance and discipline. • What schools and policymakers should consider when implementing cellphone restrictions. • What role smartphones may play in the broader decline in student academic performance. Figlio is the Gordon Fyfe Professor of Economics and Education at the University of Rochester’s School of Arts & Sciences and Warner School of Education & Human Development. Connect with him by clicking on his profile. 

Need Election Day Experts? We've Got 'Em! featured image

2 min

Need Election Day Experts? We've Got 'Em!

As voters head to the polls, University of Rochester political scientists James Druckman and Gerald Gamm are available to help journalists make sense of the results — and what they could mean for American democracy, Congress, political parties, and the polarized electorate. James Druckman: Understanding partisanship and the American electorate Druckman is a leading scholar of political partisanship and its effects on American democracy. He can help reporters interpret voter behavior, identify emerging trends, and understand what election results reveal about the deepening divide between Democrats and Republicans. His 2024 book, Partisan Hostility and American Democracy: Explaining Political Divisions and When They Matter (University of Chicago Press), has been called a “stand out” among the scholarship examining political division. New York Times columnist Thomas Edsall has highlighted Druckman among the political scientists “working on getting us to hate one another less.” Druckman is available for interviews before, during, and after Election Day to discuss voting trends, partisan dynamics, and the implications for American democracy. Connect with him by clicking on his profile. Gerald Gamm: What election results mean for Congress and governing A political scientist and historian, Gamm studies American politics, political development, legislatures, political parties, and state and local government. His expertise is particularly relevant to questions about the balance of power in Congress and statehouses, how political parties respond to shifting electoral fortunes, and what election outcomes mean for governing. Gamm is a co-author of Steering the Senate (Cambridge University Press, 2025), a study of institutional leadership and capacity on Capitol Hill that has been described as “essential reading” for anyone concerned about the future of congressional leadership. He is available for interviews before, during, and after Election Day to provide context on emerging political trends, election outcomes, and their implications for Congress and the broader political landscape. Connect with Gamm by clicking on his profile.

View all posts