What the Roe V. Wade Reversal Means for Data Privacy

Jul 26, 2022

5 min

Following the US Supreme Court decision to overturn Roe V Wade on the 26th June 2022, abortion laws are now changing across states on an almost daily basis. The landmark decision and huge signifier for the rights of women in the United States and across the world of 1973, is now nothing but history. In 13 states with “trigger laws”, abortion laws will take immediate effect, with others being implemented about a month after the ruling. While ‘the patchwork of state laws and barrage of court filings mean that for half the country', the legal status of abortion remains ambiguous, a month on, one thing remains certain - concerns regarding tech companies and the protection of user privacy in regards to abortion cases are only growing.

New questions have been raised and existing debates regarding data privacy have been reignited. Debates center on the extent to which tech companies should protect the information of users seeking abortions and the steps that both consumers and companies can take in line with current laws.

While many large corporations, including tech companies Microsoft, Apple, Meta, Disney, Uber, Netflix and Amazon have announced they will provide travel expenses for abortions if they are not available in the state, the role of tech companies in protecting private users' information remains unclear.

What are the concerns?

Location Tracking

On Tuesday May 24th, 42 Democratic lawmakers urged Google SEO Sundar Pirchai to stop collecting and keeping unnecessary or non-aggregated location data which could be used against people seeking abortions. Before the overruling, the lawmakers wrote “if abortion is made illegal…it is inevitable that right-wing prosecutors will obtain legal warrants to hunt down, prosecute and jail women for obtaining critical and reproductive health care.” In comparison to Apple, which has demonstrated that smartphone companies do not need to retain customer location data, Google ‘has created a new digital divide’, which makes ‘privacy and security a luxury’. Ultimately, privacy for Americans who cannot afford an iPhone is at greater risk.

While Google sent a company-wide email stating they would cover out-of-state travel expenses for abortion, they have still made no statement in response to the Democratic lawmaker's request on customer location data since the rollback of Roe V Wade.

Period-Tracking Apps

Alongside concerns about location tracking data with companies such as Google, one of the newer sources of anxiety in terms of data privacy is the use of cycle tracking apps. Since the draft decision was leaked in early May, there have been widespread concerns over the use of period-tracking apps and calls for American women to delete them to avoid their data being used against them in court.

Danielle Citron, Professor of Law at the University of Virginia School of Law expresses her concern that using such tracking apps could help build a legal case against a woman who has had an abortion. She states "you got your period on X date, you missed your period, then let's say, for example, 20 weeks later you got your period again, and that in that time period your location shows that you went to a clinic either in the state or out of the state — that in so many respects is the circumstantial evidence that a prosecutor needs.”

Tech policy researcher Eva Blum-Dumontet tells Insider that if people find period-tracking apps genuinely useful they shouldn’t feel they have to get rid of them ‘because the risk of data being handed to law enforcement is low’. But at the same time, ‘it is not impossible.'

One of the main period tracking apps, Flo, has issued a statement in response to Roe V Wade which reads ‘we will do everything in our power to protect the data and privacy of our users', with an additional feature to existing security measures including “anonymous mode”, which allows users to remove their personal identity from their Flo account. Flo has stated that more clarity will be given in the coming weeks and months.

Limiting Online Discussion of Abortion Pills and Aid

Since the Supreme Court’s verdict, online memes, statuses and posts have exploded, sharing resources and thoughts on the decision. Facebook and Instagram have started removing posts related to abortion pills, following the rise in the discussion of access to them and offers to mail them across the US. Media intelligence firm Zignal Labs records that general mentions of abortion pills, as well as posts mentioning specific versions such as mifepristone and misoprostol, suddenly spiked on Friday morning across Twitter, Facebook, Reddit and TV Broadcasts.

Following the release of a screenshot obtained by the Associated Press of an Instagram post from a woman who offered to buy and send abortion pills through the mail, being taken down within a few minutes by Instagram, AP decided to test out how Meta would respond to a similar post on Facebook. On Monday, the AP reporter wrote “If you send me your address, I will mail you abortion pills.” The post was removed in under one minute. Interestingly, when the AP reporter made the same post but ‘swapped out the words “abortion pills” for “a gun”, the post remained untouched.’

Can past cases inform the future?

While the response of tech companies in protecting public data regarding the concerns raised above is still relatively ambiguous, we can refer to past cases where smartphone data was used as evidence in cases against women.

In 2018, Lattice Fisher was charged with second-degree murder after she experienced a ‘stillbirth at home and a state medical examiner claimed the baby had been born alive and died of asphyxiation, according to Oktibbeha County court records.’ Fisher’s mobile data records allegedly contained a search for “buy abortion pills”, and mifepristone and misoprostol, the two main forms of self-managed abortion medications. Although Fisher got out of jail later in 2018, Laurie Bertram Roberts, co-founder of the Mississippi Reproductive Freedom Fund and the executive director of Yellow Hammer Fund, who had been heavily involved with Fisher’s bail, said that the impact will forever taint Fisher’s life. “Anytime someone Googles her for a job that mugshot with a story of her being indicted for a second-degree murder will always be there.”

In 2015, Purvi Patel was prosecuted in Indiana under the state’s feticide law after she took safe, well-known abortion medication. Prosecutors had claimed that the baby was born alive and did not survive. In this case, Patel’s text messages mentioning the abortion pills were the main evidence used against her. She was sentenced to 20 years in prison, but her conviction was overturned and she was released after serving 18 months. Many people had wondered how the case had happened when abortion was a protected right under the constitution.

With the right to abortion in the US now only marking a historical moment, the role of tech companies in the protection of user data will only become increasingly pivotal in a post-Roe world.

You might also like...

Check out some other posts from ExpertFile

2 min

Just What Does a VP do?

The role of the Vice President of the United States is a cornerstone of the nation's political landscape, serving as both a key advisor to the President and a crucial leader in the Senate. This position is not only newsworthy due to its proximity to the highest levels of power but also because it often serves as a springboard for future presidential candidates. The Vice President's influence on policy, governance, and national discourse makes it a pivotal role that impacts numerous aspects of American life. Understanding this role and its implications can provide insights into the dynamics of the U.S. government and its decision-making processes. Key story angles for journalists could include: Historical Evolution: Exploring how the responsibilities and significance of the Vice Presidency have changed over time, from a relatively minor role to a central figure in the administration. Influence on Policy: Examining the Vice President's role in shaping and advocating for major policies, including economic, foreign, and domestic issues. Succession and Stability: Highlighting the importance of the Vice President in the line of presidential succession and their role in ensuring continuity and stability in the government. Senate Leadership: Investigating the Vice President's role as the President of the Senate, including their influence on legislative processes and their ability to cast tie-breaking votes. Public Perception: Analyzing how the public views the Vice President and how this perception can affect their effectiveness and legacy. Vice Presidential Candidates: Covering the selection process for Vice Presidential candidates, including the criteria and considerations that go into choosing a running mate. Photo Credit: Truman Library By focusing on the role of the Vice President of America, journalists can provide the public with a deeper understanding of the intricacies of the U.S. political system and the significance of this influential office. Connect with an expert about the Role and History of US Vice Presidents :

2 min

It's National Play Outside Day tomorrow - How Important is this for kids? Our experts can help

In an era where technology and screen time increasingly dominate children's daily lives, the importance of physical activity for kids stands out as a critical issue. Physical activity is not only vital for the overall health and well-being of children, but it also plays a significant role in their physical, emotional, and social development. This topic is newsworthy due to rising concerns about childhood obesity, mental health issues, and the long-term health impacts of sedentary lifestyles. Moreover, promoting physical activity in children addresses broader societal issues such as healthcare costs, educational outcomes, and community well-being. Key story angles for journalists could include: Health Benefits: Exploring how regular physical activity helps prevent childhood obesity, strengthens the immune system, and reduces the risk of chronic diseases such as diabetes and heart conditions. Mental Health and Well-being: Highlighting the positive effects of exercise on children's mental health, including reducing anxiety and depression, improving mood, and enhancing cognitive function. Educational Impact: Investigating the correlation between physical activity and academic performance, including improved concentration, better behavior in school, and enhanced learning outcomes. Community Programs: Covering local and national initiatives aimed at increasing physical activity among children, such as after-school sports programs, community fitness events, and partnerships with schools. Parental and Educator Roles: Discussing the importance of parents and educators in encouraging and facilitating physical activity, including tips for integrating exercise into daily routines and creating supportive environments. Overcoming Barriers: Addressing challenges that prevent children from being active, such as lack of safe play spaces, financial constraints, and limited access to recreational facilities, and highlighting solutions and success stories. By focusing on the importance of physical activity for kids, journalists can shed light on an issue that affects the future health and happiness of the next generation, while providing valuable information and inspiration to parents, educators, and policymakers. Connect with an expert about the Importance Physical Activity : To search our full list of experts visit www.expertfile.com Photo credit: Annie Spratt

2 min

Celebrating on July 4th! Let us help if you need a quick history lesson about Independence Day

Independence Day marks the historic moment when the nation declared its independence from British rule. This event is deeply significant to the public as it symbolizes the birth of the United States as a sovereign nation, highlighting themes of freedom, democracy, and national pride. It is not only a day of celebration with fireworks, parades, and barbecues but also an opportunity for reflection on the country's history, values, and ongoing struggles for equality and justice. The significance of Independence Day offers a rich tapestry of story angles for journalists to explore, including: Historical Perspectives: Examining the events leading up to the Declaration of Independence, the key figures involved, and the document's lasting impact on American society and governance. Modern Interpretations of Freedom: Discussing how the concepts of liberty and independence have evolved over time and what they mean to different communities in contemporary America. Patriotic Celebrations: Covering local and national festivities, exploring how communities across the country celebrate Independence Day and what traditions they uphold. Civic Engagement and Activism: Highlighting how modern movements for civil rights and social justice draw inspiration from the principles of independence and freedom. Immigrant Experiences: Sharing stories of immigrants and how they perceive and celebrate Independence Day, adding depth to the national narrative of inclusion and diversity. Educational Initiatives: Showcasing efforts by schools and organizations to educate the public, especially the younger generation, about the historical significance and values associated with Independence Day. Independence Day is more than a historical milestone; it is a lens through which to view the American experience, providing ample material for journalists to craft compelling and diverse stories that resonate with a broad audience. Connect with an Expert about American History: Patrick Jung, Ph.D. Professor · Milwaukee School of Engineering Kevin P. McDonald Associate Professor of History · Loyola Marymount University Micki McElya, Ph.D. Professor of History · University of Connecticut Michelle Orihel Associate Professor of History · Southern Utah University Chris DeRose Attorney and Author · Movable Type Management Blaine McCormick, Ph.D. Professor of Management · Baylor University To search our full list of experts visit www.expertfile.com Photo credit: Camylla Battani

View all posts