Higher Education Enters the Ring

What Linda McMahon’s Appointment Means for Colleges & Universities

Nov 21, 2024

6 min

Peter Evans


Why it matters


Yesterday’s announcement that Linda McMahon is President-elect Donald Trump’s pick to lead the Department of Education ushers in a new era for universities and colleges.  This signals a sharp pivot toward decentralization and pro-business policies, and it's expected that McMahon’s leadership will focus on dismantling traditional federal education structures, expanding school choice, and aligning education priorities with a business-first agenda.  Higher education faces funding uncertainties, new accountability pressures, and the need to demonstrate its relevance in supporting economic growth.


The Big Picture


McMahon’s appointment reflects Trump’s broader strategy to reframe education policy in a way that prioritizes state control, entrepreneurship, and conservative cultural values. This will likely have significant consequences for higher education, including:


Decentralization: Shifting control of education policy and funding to the states.


School Choice Expansion: Redirecting public funds to private, religious, and homeschooling options.


Economic Alignment: Pressuring institutions to support industry, small business, and workforce development through research, partnerships, and entrepreneurship/startup programs.


Cultural Shifts: Rolling back policies on diversity, equity, and inclusion while emphasizing “patriotic” education.



What’s at Stake


Federal Funding Cuts:

Threat: Research funding, Pell Grants, and other federal supports may face cuts.

Reality Check: Congressional approval is required to eliminate funding streams like Title I, making complete federal withdrawal unlikely but changes and funding disruptions possible.


Policy Shifts:

Threat: Federal oversight will likely weaken, and policies favoring vocational and workforce-aligned education will likely put increased pressure on programs such as liberal arts. Universities will also likely face increasing pressure to align with ideological goals, such as restricting DEI (diversity, equity, and inclusion) initiatives.  The new administration could wield considerable control over the school accreditation process, which has been seen by some to force ideological changes on campuses.  There has been a movement to decentralize accreditation authority, reduce federal oversight, and align educational standards with conservative values. According to the Council for Higher Education, many of the ideas put forward focus on empowering states to authorize accrediting agencies and even serve as accreditors themselves, shifting control from federal to state governments. 

Action: Institutions must better identify their options amidst a rapidly evolving agenda at both the state and federal levels, develop strategies and secure the resources necessary.  For instance, there are calls to prohibit accreditors from requiring institutions to implement Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) policies.  Institutions also need to understand what the implications of a more diverse accreditation landscape could be, with standards varying significantly across states, potentially affecting the uniformity and transferability of academic credentials nationwide. 


Reputational Risks:

Concern: Growing public skepticism toward higher education undermines enrolment and support.

Impact: Conservative narratives favoring alternatives like apprenticeships and other programs that support the economy and job growth will likely gain traction.


Preserving Institutional Independence:

Pressure: Universities face increased scrutiny of their course curriculum and research priorities that may be deemed ideologically contentious.

Opportunity: Institutions must tangibly demonstrate their value to society. The more they can do to break down barriers between “town and gown” and counter the narrative that paints them as too expensive, elitist, and out of touch.


Demonstrating Economic Impact:

Need: Universities must showcase their role in driving economic growth through research, commercialization, and support for small businesses and entrepreneurs.

Opportunity: Institutions should communicate their relevance in relatable ways that engage with businesses, emphasizing tangible contributions to research innovation and job creation as a positive return on investment that can be messaged to taxpayers.



Key Questions for Higher Ed Leaders


Funding: How can we diversify revenue streams and reduce reliance on federal support?

Advocacy: How should universities engage state and federal leaders to protect their interests?

Reputation: How can higher education rebuild public trust and counter skepticism? 

Relevance: How do we better communicate the value of university research and its role in supporting a pro-business agenda?

Adaptation: Can institutions innovate by expanding industry partnerships, online education, and workforce-aligned programs?



Implications of Project 2025


Project 2025 is a comprehensive initiative spearheaded by the Heritage Foundation, a conservative think tank, aiming to reshape the U.S. federal government through a conservative lens. Launched in April 2023, it serves as a strategic blueprint for a potential conservative administration, detailing policy proposals, personnel strategies, training programs, and a 180-day action plan.


Analysis from the Brookings Institution states that "many proposals in Project 2025 would require an unlikely degree of cooperation from Congress, though others could be enacted unilaterally by a second Trump administration.”  While we don’t know the full extent to which Project 2025 will be implemented, its agenda seeks to reshape federal agencies, including the Department of Education, with a significant impact on the sector.  Key areas of focus include:


Title I and Student Aid

Proposals to give parents more control over federal funds could deprioritize public education.


Tax Credits for School Choice

Incentives to support private school tuition may shift K-12 pipelines, impacting university enrolment.


Economic Realignment

Universities will need to align with business priorities, emphasizing innovation, commercialization, and job creation.


Diversity Equity & Inclusion

Project 2025 explicitly calls for reducing federal spending on what it deems unnecessary or politicized initiatives, and DEI programs are likely to fall under this categorization.  This could have wide-ranging impacts, including changes to school ranking systems that have a DEI component.  Ranking bodies such as US News & World Report may need to adjust their methodologies to account for changes in diversity initiatives and data availability. With potential reductions in diversity-related data, rankings might place greater emphasis on other factors such as academic performance, faculty qualifications, and post-graduate outcomes.

This also could extend to endowments, which direct funding toward diversity programs through scholarships and fellowships. For institutions that rely heavily on DEI as a cornerstone of their fundraising and donor relations strategies, they may experience reduced donor enthusiasm, particularly from philanthropic organizations or alumni committed to these causes.


Regulatory Rollbacks

There is the potential for significant changes to Title IX protections and federal loan forgiveness programs, creating legal and financial uncertainty.



What Universities Can Do Now:


Secure Funding

  • Build relationships with private donors, businesses, and industry partners.
  • Strengthen advocacy efforts at the state level to safeguard funding & other resources.  
  • Adopt proactive strategies to mitigate potential policy impacts, such as diversifying revenue sources, engaging donors with aligned government priorities, and ensuring compliance with evolving regulations.


Reinforce Public Trust

  • Explain complex topics in accessible ways to help the public and policymakers make informed decisions.
  • Help promote and support faculty who can serve as credible sources for the media, countering misinformation and fostering informed dialogue.
  • Strengthen community connections with your experts through public speaking engagements, workshops, and local events. Position the university as a hub for knowledge and innovation that benefits the community.
  • Capitalize on the reach and influence of alumni. Highlight their successes to show how they benefitted from educational programs and research. Position them as important role models and advocates in the community who are contributing to economic growth.


Demonstrate Relevance

  • Showcase faculty and their research breakthroughs. Demonstrate how their work benefits industries, supports entrepreneurship and addresses societal challenges.
  • Speak to real-world outcomes in health, technology, the environment, and more. Use accessible language to connect with policymakers, business leaders and taxpayers.


Strengthen Advocacy:

  • Partner with peer institutions to shape policy discussions. Position universities and colleges as vital contributors to a pro-business agenda.


Innovate:

  • Expand stackable credentials and micro-credential programs that are aligned with private and public sector requirements and emerging skills-based models.
  • Look at new online education options.
  • Embrace partnerships that connect academic research to real-world economic impact.

Universities must deliver a more compelling, data-driven, yet humanized story about their institution’s contributions, fostering stronger relationships with government, the private sector, and taxpayers.


What's Next


This new era will most certainly challenge higher education to rethink its approach to funding, policy, and public engagement. For all institutions, both public and private, there is no place to hide.  As they step into the ring, Higher Education leaders will need lots of support as they look to forge new paths for research, teaching, and community service while engaging their stakeholders in ways that more powerfully communicate their vital contributions to society.

The bell has rung—are you ready?



Connect with:
Peter Evans

Peter Evans

Co-Founder & CEO

Recognized speaker on expertise marketing, technology and innovation

Media TrendsThought LeadershipMarketingTechnologyInnovation

You might also like...

Check out some other posts from ExpertFile

2 min

#ExpertSpotlight: The Day That Redefined America: 9/11 and Its Lasting Impact

September 11, 2001 marked a pivot in American history—a day when the nation’s sense of safety was shattered, and its collective identity reshaped. The attacks triggered sweeping changes in security, government authority, social behavior, and even cultural cohesion. Today, the legacy of 9/11 lives on in how we remember, govern, and connect. A Nation in Shock—and Unity On that fall morning, the U.S. witnessed a tragedy that killed nearly 3,000 people and devastated the nation’s psyche. In the immediate aftermath, grief turned into solidarity—as most Americans tuned into televised coverage, felt sadness, anger, and fear, yet paradoxically came together in an extraordinary show of patriotism and trust in institutions. In the months that followed, confidence in government reached levels unseen in decades—fueled by mourning, resolve, and a collective desire to heal. The Rise of “Homeland Security” & Executive Power Almost immediately, the U.S. government unleashed legal and structural transformations. The USA PATRIOT Act, passed just weeks later in October 2001, significantly expanded surveillance and law enforcement powers for domestic security—raising ongoing concerns about civil liberties. Alongside this, the Department of Homeland Security was created in 2002, bringing together 22 agencies to coordinate security against future threats and reinforcing a new era of national vigilance. Economic Shock and Air Travel Overhaul The attacks triggered immediate economic consequences: U.S. stock markets plunged, airlines and insurers suffered heavy losses, and GDP forecasts were revised downward. Meanwhile, the aviation sector underwent a rapid and lasting modernization in security protocols and flight routing. Notably, Canada’s Operation Yellow Ribbon absorbed diverted flights in the chaos, highlighting international cooperation amid crisis. Legal Precedents and Global Conflict Congress quickly approved the broad-ranging Authorization for Use of Military Force (AUMF), enabling the U.S. to pursue adversaries globally—a mandate that has since been interpreted far beyond its original context, shaping nearly two decades of “forever wars.” These legal expansions—and the accompanying conflicts in Afghanistan and Iraq—signaled a new global posture that redefined American foreign policy. Remembering, Serving, and the Legacy Continues In the years since, public memory of 9/11 has evolved—from solemn remembrance to proactive service. Patriot Day, proclaimed a national day of mourning and service, now encourages millions of Americans each year to volunteer in honor of those lost and the unity felt afterward. These acts of service continue to reflect the enduring spirit of resilience and community. Connect with our experts on the history, significance, and lasting impact of 9/11 on American life and policy. Check out our experts here : www.expertfile.com

2 min

Are you ready for some football?

From its modest beginnings in the late 19th century to becoming America’s most-watched sport, professional football has not only entertained generations but also transformed communities, economies, and culture. Today, the National Football League (NFL) stands as a global brand, symbolizing both the triumphs and tensions of American life. Early Beginnings Professional football took root in the 1890s, when athletic clubs in Pennsylvania began paying players under the table. In 1920, a group of teams formed the American Professional Football Association, later renamed the NFL in 1922. Early decades were marked by instability, but the league grew steadily, and by the 1950s, with the rise of television, football began capturing national attention. The 1958 NFL Championship Game—dubbed the “Greatest Game Ever Played”—cemented football as America’s sport of the future, setting the stage for the AFL-NFL rivalry of the 1960s and the eventual Super Bowl, first played in 1967. Economic Impact Football is now one of the most powerful economic engines in American sports. The NFL generates more than $18 billion annually, with billions flowing into local economies through stadium construction, tourism, and broadcasting rights. Super Bowl weekend alone can inject hundreds of millions of dollars into host cities. The game has also reshaped industries—from sports broadcasting and advertising to fantasy leagues and legalized sports betting. It drives sponsorships, merchandise sales, and jobs connected to media, hospitality, and infrastructure. Social and Cultural Significance Football’s reach extends beyond the field. It has served as a stage for some of America’s most important social conversations—from racial integration in the 1940s, to gender roles in sports media, to the modern debates over player safety and activism. Figures like Jackie Robinson in baseball broke barriers, but in football, trailblazers such as Kenny Washington (first African American to reintegrate the NFL in 1946) helped reshape opportunity and inclusion. In more recent years, high-profile advocacy by players on issues ranging from racial justice to mental health has placed the sport squarely in the middle of national debates. At the same time, concerns about concussions and long-term health risks have fueled public dialogue on workplace safety and medical ethics, echoing issues seen across many industries. A Lasting Legacy Football is more than a game. It has become a unifying tradition—whether through Friday night lights in small towns, college rivalries that galvanize entire states, or Super Bowl Sunday as an unofficial national holiday. Its economic and cultural significance continues to expand, reflecting both America’s passion for competition and its ongoing social evolution. Connect with our experts about the history and significance of professional football in America: Check out our experts here : www.expertfile.com

2 min

ExpertSpotlight: The History of Labor Day

What began as a modest parade in New York City has grown into a national holiday that honors the contributions of American workers and continues to spark conversations about labor rights today. Observed on the first Monday of September, Labor Day is both a tribute to the workforce and a cultural milestone marking the close of summer. From Parade to Holiday The first Labor Day celebration took place on September 5, 1882, when roughly 10,000 workers marched through New York City in a demonstration organized by the Central Labor Union. The parade, followed by a picnic and speeches, was designed to showcase the unity and strength of trade and labor organizations. The origins of the idea remain contested. Some credit Peter J. McGuire, co-founder of the United Brotherhood of Carpenters, while others point to Matthew Maguire, a machinist and secretary of the Central Labor Union. Regardless of its champion, the concept spread quickly. By the late 1880s, states began adopting Labor Day as an official holiday. In 1894, following a wave of labor unrest that included the Pullman Strike, President Grover Cleveland signed legislation declaring the first Monday in September a federal holiday. Labor Day vs. May Day Unlike May Day (May 1)—which became closely associated with international labor movements and the more radical legacy of the Haymarket Affair of 1886—Labor Day was intended as a uniquely American holiday. Its September placement emphasized unity and recognition without the confrontational overtones of May Day. Over time, this distinction gave Labor Day a broader cultural resonance in the United States. A Living Tradition While barbecues, parades, and retail sales now dominate many Labor Day weekends, the holiday’s deeper meaning endures. It is a reminder of the hard-won gains of the labor movement, from the eight-hour workday to workplace safety protections, as well as the continuing debates over wages, unionization, and economic fairness. Even traditions like the etiquette rule of not wearing white after Labor Day reflect how the holiday shaped cultural norms at the turn of the 20th century. Today, beyond its role as summer’s unofficial finale, Labor Day continues to honor the dignity and achievements of working people across the country. Connect with our experts about the History of Labor Day. Check out our experts here : www.expertfile.com

View all posts