Academic Freedoms are Now on the Ballot as State Legislators Seek More Control Over Institutions and Their Experts.

Draft

4 min

Peter Evans

Last month, President Biden had a very direct message for colleges and universities looking to navigate through the choppy waters of state politics in the face of the recent US Supreme Court decision to overturn Roe. v. Wade.


As Idaho state legislators get to work rolling out its “trigger ban,” President Biden bashed the University of Idaho over its new guidance against offering birth control for students.


“Folks, what century are we in? What are we doing? I respect everyone’s view on this — personal decision they make. But, my lord, we’re talking about contraception here. It shouldn’t be that controversial,” Biden said during last month's meeting of the White House Task Force on Reproductive Healthcare Access.


Image: White House Task Force on Reproductive Healthcare Access Meeting


However the new policy by the University of Idaho goes further and advises employees not to speak about reproductive rights at work and warns they could face a felony conviction for promoting abortion, The Washington Post reported.


While President Biden warned other universities to not enact the same policies.

and said that Education Secretary Miguel Cardona will look at steps to protect college students and school employees in Idaho or other states where access to contraception is at risk, these events are sparking a larger debate around academic freedom.


With such a polarized political landscape dividing much of the country on key issues such as abortion, should we be worried about what’s next? How do these actions in effect suppress important research and informed perspectives provided by academics? While state governments as critical funding sources for higher education have wielded considerable influence, these more overt actions to sanction freedom of speech is a disturbing trend.


Academics, researchers and staff within an institution require rights and privileges essential to the fulfilment of primary functions: instruction; the pursuit of knowledge and service to the community. Central among these rights is the freedom, within the law, for faculty experts to pursue what seems to them as relevant avenues of inquiry, to teach and to learn unhindered by external or non-academic constraints, and to engage in full and unrestricted consideration of any opinion.


Critics argue that suppression of these freedoms, whether by the government, the officers of the institution, or the actions of private individuals, would prevent a University from carrying out its primary functions.


A core principle of scholarship is the freedom to express ideas through respectful dialogue and the pursuit of open discussion, without risk of censure.


Other Universities Have Taken a Different Stance...


Vanderbilt University 


This argument has been supported by other schools and the examples they have set. School officials at Vanderbilt University in Tennessee, where a near-total ban on abortions took effect within the state in August, coordinated a reproductive-health task force and announced stronger support for reproductive health and parenting, even appointing a new leader to convene these resources for the University, The Washington Post reports. Elsewhere we are also seeing similar support by State University Officials in Michigan where a 1931 ban has been ruled unenforceable by the courts.


The University of Michigan 


In the lead-up to the Roe V Wade reversal, The University of Michigan created an abortion-care task force of experts to reduce the potential impact of a state-wide ban, created by Mary Sue Coleman, the president of the University of Michigan, as reported by The Detroit News.


Coleman wrote “I will do everything in my power as President to ensure we continue to provide this critically important care.” in a statement in June, after the Supreme Court ruling. The president told The Detroit News that "we have a female-dominated institution; we care about our own communities as well as those we serve through clinical care and education," Coleman said. "I am deeply concerned about how prohibiting abortion would affect UM's medical teaching, our research, and our service to communities in need.”


Concerns regarding the imminent crackdown on University campuses on the discussion and offer of birth control to students were expressed by many University officials in the months leading up to Idaho’s guidance on the matter. Dee Fenner, co-chair of the task force and chair of the Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology at Michigan Medicine spoke of the clinical and educational impacts of an abortion ban in Michigan, as reported by The Detroit News.


"The most serious consequences will be felt in the university’s clinical care realm, by patients without financial or logistical resources to access out-of-state abortion care — disproportionately people of colour, adolescents and those in rural Michigan," Fenner said. “But the impact will be felt in our classrooms as well, where pregnancy, undesired birth or complications of unsafe abortion may impact educational attainment.”


Another consideration will be the additional “brain drain” that institutions in these states will experience with faculty experts leaving for institutions with less restrictive policies. It also could have a significant impact on recruitment as more students choose schools where their reproductive rights are protected.


Speaking to the Michigan Daily, a sophomore at the University of Michigan, Miya Brado describes the day that it was announced Michigan had enough signatures as “one of the best days ever”, with the hard work “finally paying off.”


We must recognize this fundamental principle and must share responsibility for supporting, safeguarding and preserving this central freedom.


Behaviour that obstructs free and full discussion, not only of ideas that are safe and accepted but of those which may be unpopular, vitally threatens the integrity of our educational and research institutions.


Connect with:
Peter Evans

Peter Evans

Co-Founder & CEO

Recognized speaker on expertise marketing, technology and innovation

Strategic PlanningAngel InvestingOnline MediaSoftware as A Service (Saas)Technology

You might also like...

Check out some other posts from ExpertFile

2 min

What is an Open Convention?

In the ever-evolving landscape of American politics, the concept of an open convention stands as a pivotal event that can reshape the trajectory of a presidential election. This topic is particularly newsworthy because it signifies a departure from the traditional, predetermined nominating processes, opening up a dynamic and potentially unpredictable political battleground. Understanding an open convention is crucial for the public as it underscores the democratic principles of debate, decision-making, and party unity, or lack thereof. The implications of an open convention extend to voter engagement, party strategies, and the broader political discourse. Key story angles for journalists could include: Historical Context and Precedents: Exploring past instances of open conventions in American history, their outcomes, and how they have influenced subsequent elections. Mechanics and Process: Detailing how an open convention operates, the rules and procedures involved, and the roles of delegates and party officials. Political Strategy and Maneuvering: Analyzing the strategies employed by candidates and their campaigns during an open convention, including coalition-building, negotiations, and power plays. Impact on Voter Perception: Investigating how an open convention affects public opinion, voter trust, and engagement with the political process. Potential Outcomes and Scenarios: Examining the possible scenarios that can emerge from an open convention, including contested nominations, brokered deals, and unexpected candidacies. Expert Insights and Analysis: Featuring commentary and analysis from political scientists, historians, and party insiders on the significance and implications of an open convention. By focusing on the intricacies and potential ramifications of an open convention, journalists can provide the public with a comprehensive understanding of this critical aspect of the American political system, offering diverse and compelling angles for coverage. Connect with an expert if you need to know more about Open Conventions: To search our full list of experts visit www.expertfile.com Photo credit: PBS Learning Media

2 min

ExpertSpotlight: History of the Ancient Olympics

The Ancient Olympics, originating in Olympia, Greece, over 2,700 years ago, hold profound significance not only as a cornerstone of ancient Greek culture but also as a foundation for the modern Olympic Games. This topic matters to the public because it provides insights into the origins of organized sports, the cultural values of ancient civilizations, and the historical continuity that connects past traditions to contemporary global events. Understanding the history of the Ancient Olympics offers a unique perspective on the evolution of sportsmanship, competition, and international unity. Key story angles for journalists could include: Origins and Cultural Significance: Exploring the roots of the Ancient Olympics, their role in Greek society, and the religious and cultural rituals that accompanied the games. Athletic Events and Competitors: Delving into the various sports and athletic competitions that were part of the Ancient Olympics, and highlighting notable athletes and their achievements. Political and Social Impact: Investigating how the Ancient Olympics influenced political dynamics and social structures within ancient Greece, including the games' role in fostering unity and diplomacy among city-states. Religious and Mythological Connections: Examining the religious significance of the games, including their dedication to Zeus and the mythological stories associated with Olympia and the origins of the games. Legacy and Evolution: Analyzing how the traditions and values of the Ancient Olympics have shaped the modern Olympic movement, including the continuity and changes over millennia. Archaeological Discoveries: Reporting on recent archaeological findings and research that shed new light on the Ancient Olympics, including discoveries of artifacts, structures, and inscriptions. By focusing on the history of the Ancient Olympics, journalists can provide the public with a richer understanding of how these early games laid the groundwork for modern sporting events, offering diverse and compelling angles for coverage. Connect with an expert about the History of the Ancient Olympics: To search our full list of experts visit www.expertfile.com Photo credit: Chris Karidis

2 min

ExpertSpotlight: The History of the Modern Olympics

The modern Olympics, a revival of the ancient Greek tradition, have become a global phenomenon that transcends sports, uniting countries in a celebration of athleticism, competition, and international camaraderie. This topic is newsworthy not only for its rich historical context but also for its profound impact on global culture, politics, and society. The Olympics provide a unique lens through which to examine issues of national identity, geopolitical dynamics, and the pursuit of excellence. Key story angles for journalists could include: Origins and Evolution: Exploring the revival of the Olympics in 1896 by Pierre de Coubertin, and how the games have evolved over time, including significant milestones and historical events. Economic Impact: Analyzing the financial implications of hosting the Olympics, including the costs, benefits, and long-term economic impact on host cities and countries. Political Influence: Investigating the intersection of the Olympics and politics, including instances where the games have been used as a platform for political statements, boycotts, and international diplomacy. Cultural Significance: Examining how the Olympics promote cultural exchange and understanding, highlighting the role of the games in showcasing the traditions and achievements of participating nations. Technological Advancements: Assessing the impact of technological innovations on the Olympics, from advancements in sports science and athlete training to improvements in broadcasting and viewer engagement. Social Issues: Exploring the social dimensions of the Olympics, such as gender equality, inclusivity, and the representation of minority groups, as well as the efforts to address doping and maintain the integrity of competition. By focusing on the history of the modern Olympics, journalists can provide the public with a deeper understanding of how this international event has shaped and been shaped by broader historical and contemporary trends, offering rich and diverse angles for coverage. Connect with an expert about the History of the Modern Olympics: To search our full list of experts visit www.expertfile.com Photo credit: Luca Dugaro

View all posts