3 min
Is Phone Addiction Real? The Science Is Split and the Courts Are Settling
Smartphone addiction is not a distinct disorder, argues a paper published Oct. 27 in the journal Addiction. Eli Singer, founder of Offline.now, says people worried about their phone use need a clear place to start more than a label. His two-question check takes about a minute. What the two reviews say The Addiction paper reviews the evidence and finds it does not support a separate diagnosis (Wegmann, Behrendt and Cousijn, Addiction, 2026). No diagnostic manual recognizes the condition. Estimates of how many people have it range from under 3% to about a third, depending on how it is measured. A review published Oct. 14 pulled together brain-imaging studies of people who use smartphones heavily (Liu and colleagues, Journal of Integrative Neuroscience, 2026). It found consistent differences in brain structure and activity. The authors note that the content, such as games or social media, may matter more than the phone itself. "Both reviews are useful. One asks whether this is a medical diagnosis. The other describes a habit that is hard to break. You can have a hard habit without a diagnosis." Eli Singer, founder of Offline.now What the courts have decided In March, a Los Angeles jury found Meta and YouTube negligent in the first social media addiction case to reach a verdict (AP). In August, Meta settled with 47 states and the District of Columbia for up to about $18 billion (CBS News). A second Los Angeles trial was set to open Nov. 4. TikTok, YouTube, Google, Meta and Snap all settled before it began (Tech Policy Press). Settlements are not admissions of fault. The companies say there is no clear link between social media use and addiction. "A jury can decide whether a product was designed to keep people hooked. Only you can decide whether your own phone use is a problem for you." Eli Singer What to do if you're worried Singer's check asks two questions: how much you want your phone habits to change, and how confident you are that you can change them. Your answers point to one of four starting places. He gives the short answer in a Q&A on this site. If your phone use is hurting your sleep, your work or a relationship, that is a good time to talk to a professional. Offline.now's directory lists therapists and coaches who work on this. "You don't need a diagnosis to make a change. Start with two questions. How much do you want to change, and how confident are you that you can?" Eli Singer Where to start Lasting change runs on confidence, not willpower. Two questions find your starting place: Find Your Starting Place. This is general information, not medical or psychological advice. If you are dealing with severe or persistent symptoms, consider seeking qualified support. Story angles for reporters The story: courts and scientists are giving people different answers. Platforms are settling lawsuits over addictive design, while researchers still disagree on whether smartphone addiction is a distinct disorder. People worried about their own phone use are caught in between. Measuring the problem. Why estimates run from under 3% to about a third of people, depending on how the problem is measured. What settlements can't answer. What the legal cases mean, and don't mean, for one person's phone use. Where people go for help. What local therapists and coaches see in clients who are worried about their phones, with or without a diagnosis. About the expert Eli Singer is the founder of Offline.now, a directory of therapists and coaches who work on screen and phone use. He created the Offline.now Matrix and wrote Offline.now: A Practical Guide to Healthy Digital Balance. He is available to comment on the social media trials and on phone habits: eli@offline.now, or the Contact button below. The reviews: Wegmann E, Behrendt S, Cousijn J. Does smartphone addiction exist? Addiction, Oct. 27, 2026. doi:10.1111/add.70688. Liu H, Li T, Hu R, Yang P, Lei Y, Liu X. Neural Mechanisms of Smartphone Addiction: A Systematic Review of Neuroimaging and Related Neurophysiological/Neurostimulation Studies. Journal of Integrative Neuroscience, Oct. 14, 2026. doi:10.31083/JIN52647





