The Double-Edged Scroll: Why Passive Screen Time Drains You More Than Active Use

Offline.now experts say the problem isn’t just how long you’re on your phone, but what your brain is doing while you’re there and passive scrolling is the real energy thief.

Feb 5, 2026

3 min

Harshi SritharanEli Singer

Most conversations about “screen time” focus on hours. But newer research and what clinicians see in practice suggest how you use your phone may matter as much as how much you use it.


A 2024 meta-analysis of 141 studies on active vs passive social media use found that, overall, effects are small, but there is a pattern: passive use (just scrolling and watching) is more consistently associated with worse emotional outcomes, while some forms of active use (commenting, messaging, posting) show small links to greater wellbeing and online social support. (OUP Academic) Other work from Frontiers in Psychology suggests that the emotional impact of passive use depends heavily on how you feel about the content: when it triggers envy, comparison or negativity, mental ill-being goes up; when it’s genuinely positive, the effect can be neutral or even slightly protective for some users. (Frontiers) Reviews also point to upward social comparison, FOMO and rumination as key pathways linking passive browsing to lower wellbeing. (ScienceDirect)


Psychotherapist Harshi Sritharan, MSW, RSW works with teens and adults who feel “wiped out” by their feeds and draws a sharp line between passive and active tech use:


“Don’t do passive tech use — that doom scrolling, or content just being thrown at you,” she says. “I want people to engage in active tech use. Go and search something up, choose the long-form video you actually want, talk to your friends. Don’t let the app decide everything you see — especially for kids, who are getting content they’re not ready for and didn’t sign up for.”


She notes that many of her clients describe feeling “numb, anxious or wired” after long passive sessions, a sign that their nervous system is being pulled around by unpredictable, emotionally loaded content rather than chosen experiences. She also discussed the short term recall related to scrolling:


"Some of my clients can't even remember what content they consumed right after scrolling. However, we know that what we pay attention to and what we show our brains has an impact on our thoughts, mindset, feelings and overall internal world."


Offline.now founder Eli Singer frames this as a design problem, not a moral failing. The platform’s research shows people already spend about 10 of their 16 waking hours on screens; the realistic goal is to upgrade some of that time, not pretend we can all go offline. His advice: instead of vowing to “get off your phone,” start by swapping just 20 minutes a day from passive to active use; for example, messaging a friend to meet up, learning something specific, or planning an offline activity.


“When people tell us they feel overwhelmed by their screen habits, it’s not laziness, it’s a crisis of confidence,” Singer says. “We don’t need perfect digital detoxes. We need small, winnable shifts, like taking one block of passive scrolling and turning it into something you actually chose.”


For journalists, the story isn’t simply “screens are bad.” It’s that passive, algorithm-driven scrolling is where comparison, FOMO and emotional overload tend to pile up and that helping people change how they use their devices may be more realistic, and more effective, than focusing on raw minutes alone.


Featured Experts

  • Harshi Sritharan, MSW, RSW – Psychotherapist specializing in ADHD, anxiety, insomnia and digital dependency. She helps teens and adults understand how doomscrolling and passive feeds hijack dopamine and mood, and teaches practical shifts toward more intentional, “active” tech use.
  • Eli Singer – Founder of Offline.now and author of Offline.now: A Practical Guide to Healthy Digital Balance. He brings proprietary data on digital overwhelm and the “confidence gap,” and shows how 20-minute “micro-wins” like upgrading one chunk of passive screen time can change people’s relationship with their phones without extreme detoxes.


Expert interviews can be arranged through the Offline.now media team.


Connect with:
Harshi Sritharan

Harshi Sritharan

Digital Dependency Expert

Expert in digital dependency, child development, human behaviour, and behaviour modification

digital wellnesssocial media harmOnline HarmHuman BehaviourLearning Strategies‎
Eli Singer

Eli Singer

Founder and CEO

Founder of Offline.now and creator of the Offline.now Matrix. ICF-trained ADHD coach. Speaks on phone habits and screen time.

Behaviour ChangeDigital BurnoutPhubbingDigital DetoxDoomscrolling
Powered by

You might also like...

Check out some other posts from Offline.now

Is Phone Addiction Real? The Science Is Split and the Courts Are Settling featured image

3 min

Is Phone Addiction Real? The Science Is Split and the Courts Are Settling

Smartphone addiction is not a distinct disorder, argues a paper published Oct. 27 in the journal Addiction. Eli Singer, founder of Offline.now, says people worried about their phone use need a clear place to start more than a label. His two-question check takes about a minute. What the two reviews say The Addiction paper reviews the evidence and finds it does not support a separate diagnosis (Wegmann, Behrendt and Cousijn, Addiction, 2026). No diagnostic manual recognizes the condition. Estimates of how many people have it range from under 3% to about a third, depending on how it is measured. A review published Oct. 14 pulled together brain-imaging studies of people who use smartphones heavily (Liu and colleagues, Journal of Integrative Neuroscience, 2026). It found consistent differences in brain structure and activity. The authors note that the content, such as games or social media, may matter more than the phone itself. "Both reviews are useful. One asks whether this is a medical diagnosis. The other describes a habit that is hard to break. You can have a hard habit without a diagnosis." Eli Singer, founder of Offline.now What the courts have decided In March, a Los Angeles jury found Meta and YouTube negligent in the first social media addiction case to reach a verdict (AP). In August, Meta settled with 47 states and the District of Columbia for up to about $18 billion (CBS News). A second Los Angeles trial was set to open Nov. 4. TikTok, YouTube, Google, Meta and Snap all settled before it began (Tech Policy Press). Settlements are not admissions of fault. The companies say there is no clear link between social media use and addiction. "A jury can decide whether a product was designed to keep people hooked. Only you can decide whether your own phone use is a problem for you." Eli Singer What to do if you're worried Singer's check asks two questions: how much you want your phone habits to change, and how confident you are that you can change them. Your answers point to one of four starting places. He gives the short answer in a Q&A on this site. If your phone use is hurting your sleep, your work or a relationship, that is a good time to talk to a professional. Offline.now's directory lists therapists and coaches who work on this. "You don't need a diagnosis to make a change. Start with two questions. How much do you want to change, and how confident are you that you can?" Eli Singer Where to start Lasting change runs on confidence, not willpower. Two questions find your starting place: Find Your Starting Place. This is general information, not medical or psychological advice. If you are dealing with severe or persistent symptoms, consider seeking qualified support. Story angles for reporters The story: courts and scientists are giving people different answers. Platforms are settling lawsuits over addictive design, while researchers still disagree on whether smartphone addiction is a distinct disorder. People worried about their own phone use are caught in between. Measuring the problem. Why estimates run from under 3% to about a third of people, depending on how the problem is measured. What settlements can't answer. What the legal cases mean, and don't mean, for one person's phone use. Where people go for help. What local therapists and coaches see in clients who are worried about their phones, with or without a diagnosis. About the expert Eli Singer is the founder of Offline.now, a directory of therapists and coaches who work on screen and phone use. He created the Offline.now Matrix and wrote Offline.now: A Practical Guide to Healthy Digital Balance. He is available to comment on the social media trials and on phone habits: eli@offline.now, or the Contact button below. The reviews: Wegmann E, Behrendt S, Cousijn J. Does smartphone addiction exist? Addiction, Oct. 27, 2026. doi:10.1111/add.70688. Liu H, Li T, Hu R, Yang P, Lei Y, Liu X. Neural Mechanisms of Smartphone Addiction: A Systematic Review of Neuroimaging and Related Neurophysiological/Neurostimulation Studies. Journal of Integrative Neuroscience, Oct. 14, 2026. doi:10.31083/JIN52647

Did Australia's Social Media Ban Work? What One Year Shows Before Other Countries Follow featured image

3 min

Did Australia's Social Media Ban Work? What One Year Shows Before Other Countries Follow

A year after Australia banned under-16s from holding social media accounts, the share of children aged 10 to 15 with an account has fallen from 52% to 42%. Eli Singer, founder of Offline.now, points to a second number in the same study: the share still using the platforms fell only from 86% to 82%. Did the ban work? Australia's eSafety Commissioner published its evaluation on July 31, following more than 4,000 children and families (eSafety Commissioner, 2026). Fewer children held accounts, but most still used the platforms. In the first weeks, platforms removed or restricted about 4.7 million under-16 accounts (eSafety Commissioner, January 2026). The only peer-reviewed study so far surveyed 408 teens before the ban and three months after (Barnes and colleagues, BMJ, 2026). More than 85% of under-16s were still using restricted platforms. "The ban changed who can have an account. It did not change how the apps work. Teens who still get on see the same feeds as before." Eli Singer, founder of Offline.now What the court heard Reddit and the Digital Freedom Project argued in Australia's High Court on Nov. 3 and 4 that the law restricts political communication and is not working (Reuters). Government lawyers argued that the design of the platforms puts children at risk, including through addictive use and lost sleep, and that the ban is the most direct response (Startup Daily). The court has not yet ruled. "Whatever the court decides, parents will still be dealing with autoplay and endless feeds at home. That part of the problem is about design." Eli Singer Who is next United Kingdom: the same minimum age of 16, starting March 2027 (LBC). Canada: Bill C-34, tabled June 10, would set a minimum account age of 16. It is before the House of Commons (LEGISinfo). California: from Jan. 1, 2027, AB 1709 restricts personalized feeds and autoplay for anyone under 16. Tech companies filed suit on Nov. 4 to stop it (AP). The UK and Canada follow Australia's minimum-age approach. California's law targets how feeds are designed. "Canada and the UK can learn from Australia's first year. A law can set limits for the platforms. Families still decide what evenings at home look like." Eli Singer What it means for families Offline.now's summary of the year's data and the countries that are next is written for parents in Canada and the US. Singer gave his first reaction a week after the ban took effect. Where to start Lasting change runs on confidence, not willpower. Two questions find your starting place: Find Your Starting Place. Every family is different. Use what fits and consider professional support if conflict or distress feels severe. Story angles for reporters The story for Canadian, UK and US audiences: what Australia's first year shows before similar rules arrive at home. The numbers show fewer accounts and nearly the same use, and the Dec. 10 anniversary is likely to bring new figures. Accounts and use. Why the two numbers moved so differently, and what that means for enforcement. Bill C-34 in Canada. What local parents and teens think of a minimum account age of 16. Age limits or feed design. Australia's account rule compared with California's limits on feeds and autoplay. About the expert Eli Singer is the founder of Offline.now, a directory of therapists and coaches who work on screen and phone use. He created the Offline.now Matrix and wrote Offline.now: A Practical Guide to Healthy Digital Balance. He is available to comment through the Dec. 10 anniversary on youth social media laws: eli@offline.now, or the Contact button below.

What Time Should Teens Turn Off Their Phones? New Sleep Research Points to 10 p.m. featured image

3 min

What Time Should Teens Turn Off Their Phones? New Sleep Research Points to 10 p.m.

Teens who use their phones after 10 p.m. fall asleep later and sleep less, two studies published Oct. 19 and Nov. 6 found. Eli Singer, founder of Offline.now, says a set time gives families something clear to agree on, and is easier to talk about than a daily limit. What the two studies found A JAMA Pediatrics study tracked 425 US teens over more than 7,500 nights (Zhao, Hale and Christakis, JAMA Pediatrics, 2026). On nights when teens used their phones more than usual after 10 p.m., they fell asleep about an hour later and slept about 20 minutes less. A second study, published Nov. 6, recorded phone use directly on 218 teens' phones (Mathew and colleagues, Journal of Adolescent Health, 2026). More use in the evening and late at night, especially social media, went with later and shorter sleep. Both studies found a link between late phone use and sleep. Neither proves the phone is the cause. "For years, parents were told to watch a daily total. A total is hard to see and easy to argue about. A time is on the clock and out in the open, so everyone is on the same page." Eli Singer, founder of Offline.now Why a set time works better than a daily limit A daily limit counts two hours at midnight the same as two hours after school. The research points to late use as the problem, because it takes time from sleep and keeps teens alert when they should be winding down. Meta's settlement with US states will block Instagram and Facebook for under-18s from midnight to 6 a.m., two hours later than the time these studies point to (CBS News). "The time is the agreement. The charger is where it happens. If the charger is in the kitchen, or anywhere outside the bedroom, the curfew is much easier to keep." Eli Singer How to agree on a 10 p.m. curfew Singer's advice is to start with a conversation and find what works for your teen. Ask your teen what time feels fair, and agree on one together. If you can, charge every phone in the house outside the bedrooms, including the parents' phones. Expect some nights when the curfew doesn't happen. Agree ahead of time how you will start again the next night. If your teen already has trouble sleeping, Offline.now's guide to insomnia from night phone use has steps to try first. For adults, Singer's earlier post asks What Time Should You Actually Turn Off Your Phone at Night? "When a teen helps choose the time, they are more likely to stick to it. The studies point to 10 p.m. Let your teen have a say in the details." Eli Singer Where to start Lasting change runs on confidence, not willpower. Two questions find your starting place: Find Your Starting Place. This is not medical advice. If sleep issues are persistent or severe, consider talking with a qualified professional. Story angles for reporters The story: screen time advice is moving from daily totals to a set time at night. Two studies that tracked teens' phones directly point to 10 p.m., while the platforms' own overnight blocks start at midnight. Are daily limits out of date? Ask pediatricians and sleep researchers whether the time of use now matters more than the total. Platform rules and the research. Meta's overnight block starts at midnight. These studies point two hours earlier. What teens would choose. Ask local teens what curfew they think is fair, and where their phones charge at night. About the expert Eli Singer is the founder of Offline.now, a directory of therapists and coaches who work on screen and phone use. He created the Offline.now Matrix and wrote Offline.now: A Practical Guide to Healthy Digital Balance. He is available to comment this month on teen sleep and phone curfews: eli@offline.now, or the Contact button below. The studies: Zhao Y, Hale L, Christakis DA. Evening Phone Use and Sleep Outcomes Among Youth. JAMA Pediatrics, Oct. 19, 2026. doi:10.1001/jamapediatrics.2026.4902. Mathew GM, Reichenberger DA, Rodriguez IR, Christakis DA, Hale L. Objectively Measured Smartphone Use Is Associated With Worse Sleep Health Among Adolescents: The Stony Brook University MEDiA Study. Journal of Adolescent Health, Nov. 6, 2026. doi:10.1016/j.jadohealth.2026.08.039

View all posts